BRING HOME
SOME OF OUR
FAMOUS
FROZEN
DESSERTS!

Forget the icing on the cake. At Sonny’s, the cake itself is the main attraction. Our ice cream cake shop is pleased to offer a wide selection of frozen cakes with countless flavor and topping choices. Whether you want to make a splash at a birthday celebration or delight guests at a dinner party, these cakes will exceed all of your expectations. We are a family owned and operated business that also runs Nicholas Markets Foodtown, so you know you are getting the very best. (Don’t forget: We host parties at our frozen dessert shop in NJ, too)!

Choose from a frozen yogurt cake, Italian ice cake or pick up a fresh pie. Cake sizes range from 6-inch round cakes to ¼ sheet cakes. Everything is made from our top-quality ingredients and prepared on the premises. Bring something different to the table and skip the traditional ice cream cake with an original creation at our frozen dessert shop. Sonny’s is an unexpected delight that everyone will rave about!

BRING US HOME.
ENJOY AT SONNY’S HOME

FLYING SAUCERS

Vanilla soft serve sandwiched between two Oreo Cookies

CHIPWICHES

Vanilla soft serve sandwiched between two freshly baked chocolate chip cookies

MINI CHIPWICHES

Vanilla soft serve sandwiched between two freshly baked, Nicholas Markets signature Jimmy Cookies

$8.99 | 6 pack

$9.99 | 6 pack

$9.99 | 6 pack

SIGNATURE PIES$14.99

Sonny’s signature pies are made fresh daily and serve up to 8 people.

Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Cookies & Cream, Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel, Nutella, Mint Cholocate, Chip, Peanut Butter

Customizations: Available upon request at no additional charge

SIGNATURE FROZEN CAKES

Available in Vanilla/Chocolate combo OR Full Chocolate – All cakes include the classic chocolate cake crunch!

6-inch Cakes (Serves 4-8)$18.99
7-inch Cakes (Serves 8-12)$26.99
9-inch Cakes (Serves 16-24)$36.99
1/4 Sheet Cakes (Serves 24-30)$42.99
Sonny’s Pints &
Quarts To-Go
Any flavor is available
Pint$5.99
Specialy Flavor
Frozen Cake
7-inch Oreo (Serves 8-12)$28.99
7-inch Reese’s (Serves 8-12)$28.99
To place your order, visit our ice cream cake and frozen dessert shop or call us at 973-433-0770.

Explore Our Other
Frozen
Dessert Categories